Welcome to Martoni's Fire Baked Pizza, an Italian culinary gem nestled in the heart of Steubenville, Ohio. Located at 104 N 4th St, this inviting spot specializes in creating authentic fire-baked pizzas that are as delicious as they are enticing. With a variety of offerings from mouth-watering appetizers to hearty sandwiches, Martoni's has quickly become a beloved local destination for food enthusiasts.

As you step into Martoni's, the warm aroma of freshly baked dough and simmering sauces fills the air, beckoning you to indulge in their culinary creations. The star of the show, of course, is their renowned pizza, which has received rave reviews from patrons. One customer, Valerie Dreyer, described it as "probably the best pepperoni pizza and hot chocolate" she has ever had. It's clear that the quality and flavor of the ingredients used set Martoni's apart in a region known for its rich Italian offerings.

Not to be overlooked, the appetizers at Martoni's are equally delightful. Start with their Meatball Sliders, featuring four house-made beef meatballs served on soft slider buns with a generous topping of Provonello cheese. Alternatively, the Fried Zucchini is a must-try; it's perfectly battered and fried, then dusted with Romano cheese and served with a side of red pizza sauce – an irresistible treat for zucchini lovers!

Another standout is the fire-baked calzones. The Big Tony Calzone is a feast for the senses, filled with pepperoni, Italian sausage, meatballs, and bacon, combined with provonello and ricotta cheeses. Meanwhile, the Buffalo Chicken Calzone adds a spicy twist with its fire-baked chicken tossed in buffalo sauce – an adventurous delight for those who crave bold flavors.

Sandwich lovers will rejoice at the selection available, including the Steak and Cheese Sandwich packed with strips of fire-roasted steak and a blend of melted cheeses. The Loaded Steak Sandwich takes it a step further, adding fire-roasted peppers, mushrooms, and caramelized onions for an explosion of taste. Patrons like Michelle Mazzella appreciate the variety, singing praises for items like the Porky’s Revenge and the famous breadsticks.

With friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere, dining at Martoni's feels like being part of a family gathering. Customers frequently compliment the warmth of the staff, adding to the overall pleasurable dining experience. As Edward Michalo notes, it’s “great pizza that doesn’t disappoint.”

For anyone in search of a memorable Italian meal, Martoni's Fire Baked Pizza stands out as a top contender. With savory dishes that are sure to please any palate and a dedication to quality, this restaurant has solidified its place as a must-visit in the valley. So gather your friends, bring your appetite, and prepare to enjoy a feast that will leave a lasting impression.